In this PR, we update LocalBackend to set WantRunning=true when applying policy settings
to the current profile's prefs, if the "always-on" mode is enabled.
We also implement a new (*LocalBackend).EditPrefsAs() method, which is like EditPrefs
but accepts an actor (e.g., a LocalAPI client's identity) that initiated the change.
If WantRunning is being set to false, the new EditPrefsAs method checks whether the actor
has ipnauth.Disconnect access to the profile and propagates an error if they do not.
Finally, we update (*ipnserver.actor).CheckProfileAccess to allow a disconnect
only if the "always-on" mode is not enabled by the AlwaysOn policy setting.
This is not a comprehensive solution to the "always-on" mode across platforms,
as instead of disconnecting a user could achieve the same effect by creating
a new empty profile, initiating a reauth, or by deleting the profile.
These are the things we should address in future PRs.
Updates #14823
Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
The implementations define it to verify whether the actor has the requested access to a login profile.
Updates #14823
Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
In preparation for adding test coverage for ipn/ipnserver.Server, we update it
to use ipnauth.Actor instead of its concrete implementation where possible.
Updates tailscale/corp#25804
Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
We add the ClientID() method to the ipnauth.Actor interface and updated ipnserver.actor to implement it.
This method returns a unique ID of the connected client if the actor represents one. It helps link a series
of interactions initiated by the client, such as when a notification needs to be sent back to a specific session,
rather than all active sessions, in response to a certain request.
We also add LocalBackend.WatchNotificationsAs and LocalBackend.StartLoginInteractiveAs methods,
which are like WatchNotifications and StartLoginInteractive but accept an additional parameter
specifying an ipnauth.Actor who initiates the operation. We store these actor identities in
watchSession.owner and LocalBackend.authActor, respectively,and implement LocalBackend.sendTo
and related helper methods to enable sending notifications to watchSessions associated with actors
(or, more broadly, identifiable recipients).
We then use the above to change who receives the BrowseToURL notifications:
- For user-initiated, interactive logins, the notification is delivered only to the user who initiated the
process. If the initiating actor represents a specific connected client, the URL notification is sent back
to the same LocalAPI client that called StartLoginInteractive. Otherwise, the notification is sent to all
clients connected as that user.
Currently, we only differentiate between users on Windows, as it is inherently a multi-user OS.
- In all other cases (e.g., node key expiration), we send the notification to all connected users.
Updates tailscale/corp#18342
Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
Currently, we use PermitRead/PermitWrite/PermitCert permission flags to determine which operations are allowed for a LocalAPI client.
These checks are performed when localapi.Handler handles a request. Additionally, certain operations (e.g., changing the serve config)
requires the connected user to be a local admin. This approach is inherently racey and is subject to TOCTOU issues.
We consider it to be more critical on Windows environments, which are inherently multi-user, and therefore we prevent more than one
OS user from connecting and utilizing the LocalBackend at the same time. However, the same type of issues is also applicable to other
platforms when switching between profiles that have different OperatorUser values in ipn.Prefs.
We'd like to allow more than one Windows user to connect, but limit what they can see and do based on their access rights on the device
(e.g., an local admin or not) and to the currently active LoginProfile (e.g., owner/operator or not), while preventing TOCTOU issues on Windows
and other platforms. Therefore, we'd like to pass an actor from the LocalAPI to the LocalBackend to represent the user performing the operation.
The LocalBackend, or the profileManager down the line, will then check the actor's access rights to perform a given operation on the device
and against the current (and/or the target) profile.
This PR does not change the current permission model in any way, but it introduces the concept of an actor and includes some preparatory
work to pass it around. Temporarily, the ipnauth.Actor interface has methods like IsLocalSystem and IsLocalAdmin, which are only relevant
to the current permission model. It also lacks methods that will actually be used in the new model. We'll be adding these gradually in the next
PRs and removing the deprecated methods and the Permit* flags at the end of the transition.
Updates tailscale/corp#18342
Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
Nick Khyl
Nahum Shalman